Sarasota Restaurant Reviews | Dining Guide | SRQ | Florida dining

Derek’s Culinary Casual 514 Central Avenue Sarasota, FL 34236 Phone: 941-366-6565

Fax: 941-366-5353

9.3 logo-srq-small-9767645
Food Presentation Decor Service Value
10 9.5 9.5 9 8

Derek is moving his restaurant to west Manatee in Bradenton. It should be open 2013 late summer/early fall.   The Perfect Match: Derek’s Culinary Casual and the Rosemary District
Dating back to the late 1800’s the historic roots of the Rosemary District run deep; however one would not consider the area traditional.  In fact, for many years the entire area just north of downtown was a collection of neglected buildings, and open lots overlooked by locals and visitors.  In the late 1990’s efforts were initiated to renovate this historic part of Sarasota and it continues today as a work in progress.

Although the Rosemary District’s historic roots date back to the late 1800’s, one would not consider the area to be traditional.  The area can be described as edgy, innovative, up and coming, creative, and independent, with an undercurrent of historic significance; the perfect backdrop for Chef Derek Barnes to showcase his talents.

Derek’s Culinary Casual has an understated, casually elegant storefront type exterior.  This setting, marked by a simple red sign, provides an interesting contrast to the hip open kitchen, high ceilinged dining space, paneled wall coverings, and candle lit white clothed tables. One step inside and you immediately feel a serious culinary pulse.  One look at the menu and your feeling is confirmed.

Derek’s bills his cuisine as Progressive American.  The menu offers a wide selection of soups, salads, beef, lamb, duck, pork, and seafood.  Perhaps the best way to define Progressive American cuisine is by taste which ranges from familiar comfort to sophisticated layers of spice and flavor.  In other words, there is something for everyone on the menu!

For our dinners we chose the following:

Gumbo:  Pulled pork, Andouille sausage, and duck.  $4.00cup/$6.00 bowl
Rich and meaty with layers of flavor and a slight hint of spice; delicious.
Country Spinach Salad:  Baby spinach, kiln dried cherries, shaved fennel, and candied pecans, blue cheese dressing.  $9.00
Fresh, crisp, and sweet, a great way to begin a meal.
Pan Roasted Calamari:  Muffaletta toast, preserved lemon, sweet garlic emulsion.  $12.00
Sweet, spicy, a mélange of flavor and textures.
Pan Roasted American Snapper:  PEI mussels, ginger, braised turtle beans, peanuts, crispy shallots.  $30.00
A beautiful presentation of fresh fish, crunch shallots served on a velvety blend of dark beans; lick the plate good!
Grilled Gulf Shrimp:  Aged cheddar ground grits, blue crab ragout, sweet corn and okra piccalilli.  $28.00
Creamy, sweet, very satisfying, shrimp were very large and generous.
Frozen Trio:  A daily selection of fresh ice cream, sorbet and granita.  Ice cream-Keifer lime, sorbet-balsamic with aged roasted grapes, granita-grapefruit.  $6.00
Creamy, rich, and colorful, unusual, not sweet, but satisfying.

Derek’s offers a wide selection of beer and wine to accompany your meal.  Their signature bread service is a cheese puff which has a light, smooth, and creamy texture.  As one would expect, their wait staff service is friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive.

Derek’s Culinary Casual in the Rosemary District, the perfect match, innovative, creative cuisine, in an edgy up and coming part of town.

SRQ Reviews, the restaurant guide you need to find the best dining in Sarasota, Florida.

Categories: Eclectic, New American
Styles: Bistro, Fine Dining, Zone – Rosemary District

Breakfast: N/A
Lunch: N/A
Dinner: Tuesday – Saturday 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM
Late night: N/A
Entrees: $19.00 – $30.00
Reservations: Recommended
Open Air Space: Not Available
Date Reviewed: 02-11-2011
Exceptions:  Closed for lunch during the summer.

Click here for directions or a larger map.

URL: http://www.dereks-sarasota.com

Back to Review Listings